As reported in The Real Report by Joe Clements
BOSTON, MA — When Albany Road Real Estate Partners entered New England’s CRE investment arena five summers ago, the brain trust of four financial entrepreneurs led by Copley Real Estate Advisors veteran Christopher J. Knisley possessed ambitions to buy roughly $100 million annually, yet their path was initially uncharted, opening July 1st sans any prospects. “We felt it was a good time to be in the market and we decided to get things started, but we had zero idea where we were headed or what we were going to buy,” Knisley tells Real Reporter in a recent interview, so when a failing New Hampshire shopping plaza appeared on the horizon, Albany Road went that route despite being below a preferred range of $15 million to $50 million in deal size.
The portfolio launched unceremoniously on a soggy July morning where Knisley was the lone credible bidder at an on-site auction of Amherst Crossing in that Manchester suburb, an event arranged by lender TD Bank. The 129,000-sf plaza had been crippled from a loss of Circuit City during the consumer electronic chain’s massive bankruptcy and was underwater from a mortal mortgage of $20 million owed amidst the recessionary fog that hung over retail earlier this decade.
At $8.0 million, Albany Road’s basis reflected a 60 percent discount to the debt balance and a whopping 70 percent reduction on the then-appraised value of $25 million for Amherst Crossing. The capitalization rate was inflated to 11 percent from what Knisley calculates would be 2 percent lower in a less volatile scenario such as a foreclosure action, further lowering the basis.
Whatever the back- drop, “We walked away the winner, and we were off and running,” recounts Knisley, who stresses while it was cobbled together quickly, the inaugural pursuit was hardly a capricious gambit, his background steeped in retail providing a recognition any issues could be addressed. Amid all the doom-and-gloom, for example, the center was back to 97 percent occupancy by the time Albany Road took over thanks to Bed Bath & Beyond taking the fallow Circuit City space.
“It was an interesting story, a little deal that didn’t get much attention and wound up turning out great for us from a real estate perspective,” explains Knisley, a welcomed vote of confidence coming from TD Bank actually providing a $5 million loan to cement the exchange which actually closed on September 14th. “It was a nice way to kick things off,” says Knisley regarding the milestone deal first relayed by Real Reporter.
Record low interest rates for its floating rate TD loan, signing Sleepy’s Mattress to a 10-year lease renewal and landing a fitness center for another fallow building enabled Albany Road to deliver investors net cash distributions cresting 15 percent during the holding period of Amherst Crossing and its $12.0 million trade in July 2015 equates to a hale 28.3 percent levered IRR.
Albany Road went on to secure two more assets in 2012, the capital again coming through syndication of deals to high net worth individuals and other private sources. Many at the outset were admiring business associates and friends of the founders, a band who collectively brings 120 years of investment banking, real estate and venture capital experience to Albany Road, the firm so named because Knisley and partner Mark McInerney attended the private secondary school Deerfield Academy whose major thoroughfare has that handle as well.
The other founding members are Clark N. Callender and Steve Strandberg. All four serve on the Board of Managers and Albany Road’s Investment Committee.
The pace really picked in the third year, and is about to go into hyper-drive—to say the least—amid estimates from Knisley of buying between $300 million and $350 million of product annually as the company begins its trek towards a 10th anniversary milestone. The campaign is being fueled by a $200 million fund that celebrated its inaugural equity raise of $135 million on September 18th—poignantly five years and four days removed from buying Amherst Crossing—with more equity closings planned next month and in early March to a hard cap of $200 million, while a sidecar investment could generate another $150 million in equity, collectively providing upwards of $900 million in buying might.
“We have a lot of capital to deploy,” Knisley acknowledges. Reflecting on reaching the five-year mark, he says the growth coming so rapidly was unanticipated, with the $500 mil- lion level set for five years attained in spring 2016. Business went to another level from an expansion beyond the Northeast where the platform had been initially focused, buying in every New England state save for Vermont while assembling a lineup of self-storage facilities, industrial and office buildings and a large shopping center in western Massachusetts, the Springfield Plaza, bought in November 2013 for $35 million, as previously unveiled by Real Reporter.
All told, the company now has over $800 million of CRE under management repre- senting $250 million in equity covering 49 structures encompassing 6.2 million sf of industrial, office and retail real estate. The $135 million raised in the initial Fund II equity raise was partly deployed to acquire a stabilized office building in Dallas, as previously announced by the firm along with Albany Road rolling out its Southwest office in Dallas to be run by Lincoln Property Co. transplant Merrick Egan. The $21 million office deal was funded by Bank of America.
Knisley confirms to Real Reporter the group has inked an agreement to acquire a seven-building property in San Antonio, TX, at a price tag market watchers peg in the $14.5 million range. It would be the second Fund II asset. Knisley declined to discuss specifics beyond describing it is a flex/office hybrid and relaying that San Antonio is a desirable market where there are opportunities “right in our wheelhouse” to be considered. The Northbrook deal should be completed as of mid-December. Fund II is expected to contribute approximately $6 million in equity and about $1.2 million in capital improvements are expected for the 105,600-sf property presently 89 percent leased and located near two of the city’s main highways. Rents are about 7 percent below market by one as- sessment.
Albany Road has interest in Austin, Dallas and Houston as target markets, although energy sector uncertainty and Hurricane Harvey have put the latter metropolis on a back burner. Austin “is very hot but pretty expensive right now,” Knisley reports, making Dallas and San Antonio the primary areas being considered initially, as evidenced in the first two deals taking place in those communities. Egan is a longtime CRE professional active in the Dallas market, some- thing Knisley maintains will be of particular benefit for what is presently a one-person shop.
Interestingly, whereas Albany Road may have been feeling its way along in 2012, the firm has very specific strategies in mind how the Fund II portfolio will take shape, with retail and self-storage taking a back seat to industrial and office opportunities, typically in the $30 million to $40 million-sphere but also able to dip as low as $15 million and up to $50 million, and should the right situation evolve, the scope could be ratcheted upwards to a possible nine-figure opportunity.
“The premise of the fund is built around geographic and property diversification in industrial and office real estate where we will be flexible in considering different sorts of opportunities in those areas, be it medical, suburban and urban, and we anticipate a pattern of one-third invested in the Northeast, one-third spent in the Southeast and one-third going to the Southwest.” Texas is the primary focus for the latter operation which Knisley says will ultimately take about three years to establish, by which point deals will be considered in such states as Arizona, Nevada and possibly Colorado.
But the farther a field Albany Road stretches, Bay State native Knisley stresses New England is still a “tremendously important” venue for the company, relaying that along with a couple of deals being chased in the Carolinas for Fund II, there are multiple Northeast prospects being circled about, though he would not provide further insight on the targets.
“We are absolutely going to remain active in the Northeast,” he declares. “Industrial here can be expensive to buy into right now, but we are looking hard at finding the right opportunities and certainly hope we can find them in all areas.”
Preferences have shifted over time for the group, with self-storage something Albany Road was voracious towards in its formative years, landing a substantial Connecticut portfolio before the end of 2012, then assembling enough similar type product through Fund I that its sale as a package of 458,000 sf in May 2016 delivered $39.3 million, an astounding 36.6 percent IRR. The assets which were bought from 2012 to 2015 had cost $27.6 million to purchase.
According to Knisley, there may be select opportunities in self storage that come about, “but we think that market has become too expensive, even for the mom-and-pop opportunities, and so we decided not only did we not want to buy more, it was probably the best time to get out,” he says. Ultimately, “we felt we bought into that market at the right time, and we felt we exited at the right time as well.”
Retail is an area Knisley cut his teeth on professionally, “and the firm’s Springfield shopping center performs well, but “retail is a very difficult industry and product type (to invest in) today,” he cautions, whereas, “We felt there are more and better opportunities in the industrial and office segments, and so do our investors.”